Manuscript Review Form
Forms & Documents
Manuscript Review Form
Offline copy of the review form used in OJS. Reviewers should complete the review online; use this copy only if you cannot access OJS, and email it to the editor.
Who uses it Reviewers | When During peer review | Format Word (.docx) |
What reviewers assess
- Language quality and novelty of the manuscript
- Relevance to scope, title and abstract
- Literature review, methodology, results, discussion, and conclusions
- Tables and figures, and research ethics
- Overall score, comments for the authors, and confidential comments to the editor
Please also read
- The Reviewer Guidelines shown in your OJS review assignment
- The JOIN-MR AI Policy: do not upload manuscripts to AI tools
- The COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers